When The Hunger Games books and then films came out, my friends and I often discussed Katniss’s predicament of choosing between Peeta and Gale. Unpopular opinion: many days I thought maybe Katniss should just ditch the boys and be happy by herself. Other days I was solidly Team Peeta. Today, I find way too much joy in debating romantic choices made by new young adult fiction characters. (I hope you’re reading this, Sarah J. Maas.) Whether you end up loving these love triangle fantasy books, or end up loving to argue about them, let’s dive into the ultimate list of YA fantasy books with love triangles you will never forget! Need even more magical books to read after this list of YA fantasy books with love triangles? Whatever reads you’re craving, receive personalized book recommendations by signing up for Tailored Book Recommendations! You’ll never run out of something fantastic to read, trust me.